A small difference makes a big difference
In this case, an eighth of an inch cost us
an additional 3 hours. Yesterday afternoon, a group of guys from
the lab came over to my parents' house to do some car brake work.
Pieter's 1999 Jeep was suffering from some poor braking and so he
asked me for some help in fixing it. Since Jason's dad is a
mechanic and he practically grew up with a torque wrench in his
crib I asked him to come along as well. Mohammad came along to
learn and get his hands literally dirty.
Pieter had previously purchased all the parts beforehand from
Autozone, so we expected the work to be finished in one hour. The
work went by without a hitch and everything fit like it was
supposed to. We finished putting everything back together and Jason
gets into the car to pull it out of the garage. He starts the car
and puts it into reverse and lets off the brake pedal.
The car doesn't move.
He eases on the gas pedal, and the car still doesn't move. He revs
the car hard. You can see the car lunging back as if it desperately
wanted to move, but it's not going anywhere. The wheels are firmly
planted on the ground.
We were dumbfounded. Never has this happened to either Jason or I
when doing brake work. We had no idea what was going on. Did we
break something? Why were the brakes permanently engaged? We
started going through the problem-solving method, trying to narrow
the problem down to a specific part or area. The emergency brake
was off, there was no wheel chock behind the tires, and the brake
cylinder had the proper fluid level.
We took the front tires back off to see if the brakes were
permanently clamped, which we still didn't know why that could
happen. The rotor/hub turned freely. I started to put the tire back
on and as I tightened the first lug nut, I tried to spin the tire.
It was stuck.
The rotor was too big and therefore it was engaging the brake pad
when the tire was on the car. But the Autozone guy had sold Pieter
the rotors based on him saying that he had a 1999 Jeep. By this
time, it's been two hours and the guys had no choice but to go
back to the store. Turns out Jeep engineers changed the
specification in the middle of 1999 and some Jeeps got rotors/hubs
from the new 2000 model. The difference? One-eighth of an inch. And
the worst part is that there's no way to know which rotors you
have without physically taking the wheel off and visually
inspecting the rotor.
By the time they got back and put everything back together it was 10:30pm: a whole 3 hours from when we could have been done.


